Rethinking "Smart-Only" Islands

The term “smart islands“ is becoming almost as popular as “smart cities”. Both are determined by what Streitz calls the “Smart-Everything Paradigm” (Streitz, 2019), a mainly technology-driven development encountered with smart cars, smart cities, and also smart islands. It is mainly characterized by smart services based on data collected by a variety of sensors and combined with actuators as part of an Internet of Things (IoT) infrastructure, monitored and controlled by software using Artificial Intelligence (AI) or Machine Learning (ML), resulting in an increasing degree of automation and privacy infringements. Humans are increasingly removed from being the “operator” and thus in control of their interactions and decisions in virtual and physical environments. Thus, we must ask – and answer - the question: “What kind of cities and islands do we want to live in?”

 

The answer is based on Rethinking ‘Smart’ Islands Towards Self-Aware and Cooperative Hybrid Islands. Similar to the critical reflection of "smart-only" cities, there is the need for a counter proposal to "smart-only" islands. This requires a human-/citizen/islander-centered design approach for moving beyond ‘smart-only’ islands towards humane, sociable, and cooperative islands, based on the properties of self-aware hybrid islands, thus applying the lessons learned from smart cities to smart islands. Smartness is redefined as ‘self-awareness’, i.e., how much the island knows about itself and how it communicates collected data and their aggregations to its islanders and the island administration. Motivating islanders to get engaged, be part of the local community, allowing for data collection and to contribute data actively cannot be valued highly enough. It requires participatory design and keeping the islanders in the loop and to foster co-provision, co-creation, and co-exploitation. Viewing the island and its islanders as ‘mutual cooperation partners’ and developing a common purpose is the basis for a ‘Islanders <=> Island Cooperation Contract’, which regulates the necessary design trade-offs, enabling to meet the needs and to provide appropriate services. Streitz proposes also to view islands as ‘hybrid’ islands on at least three dimensions (real vs. virtual, sea vs. land, urban vs. rural) and proposed several actions to exploit the seams and transitions between them.

 

Below is the summary of the "Rethinking Smart Islands" Event that took place on 26. - 27. October 2021 in Funchal, Madeira. It was organized by the University of Madeira and ARDITI as part of the EU-funded FORWARD project. 

References

 

Norbert Streitz (2021). Rethinking ‘Smart’ Islands Towards Self-Aware and Cooperative Hybrid Islands. Keynote at the 2-Day Seminar on "Scientific Excellence in Research and Innovation", part of the FORWARD Project and organized by ARDITI and University of Madeira. Funchal, Madeira, Portugal (26.-27. October 2021)

 

Norbert Streitz (2021). From Smart-Only Cities towards Humane and Cooperative Hybrid Cities. Technology | Architecture + Design. Volume 5, Issue 2.
pp. 127 - 133. (Taylor & Francis).
DOI: 10.1080/24751448.2021.1967050

 

Norbert Streitz (2019). Beyond 'Smart-Only' Cities: Redefining the 'Smart-

Everything' Paradigm. Journal of Ambient Intelligence and Humanized Computing. Volume 10, Issue 2. pp. 791-812. (Springer). DOI: 10.1007/s12652-018-0824-1